Circumcision: A Cultural or Medical Choice? Exploring the Debate

Circumcision, the surgical removal of the foreskin from the penis, has been practiced for millennia across various cultures and religions. Today, the debate surrounding circumcision centers on whether it’s primarily a cultural or medical choice. This article delves into the historical and cultural significance of circumcision, explores the potential medical benefits and drawbacks, and examines the ethical considerations surrounding this practice in the modern world.

10 Benefits of Circumcision

While the decision to circumcise is a personal one, there are some potential medical benefits to consider. Here are 10 possible advantages of circumcision:

1. Reduced Risk of Urinary Tract Infections (UTIs) in Infancy: Circumcised babies are less likely to experience UTIs in the first year of life, although UTIs are uncommon overall in healthy infants.
2. Lower Risk of Certain Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs): Circumcision may offer a slight reduction in the risk of acquiring HIV and some other STIs like HPV (human papillomavirus) later in life. However, it’s important to emphasize that circumcision is not a guaranteed method of STI prevention, and safe sex practices are still essential.
3. Potential Protection Against Penile Cancer: Studies suggest a possible decreased risk of developing penile cancer in adulthood for circumcised men. However, penile cancer is a rare form of cancer, and the overall benefit is considered small.
4. Reduced Risk of Balanitis and Posthitis: These are inflammations of the glans (head) and foreskin, respectively. Circumcision eliminates the potential for these conditions to occur.
5. Easier Genital Hygiene: A circumcised penis might be easier to keep clean, especially for young boys who are still learning proper hygiene practices.
6. Possible Reduced Risk of Phimosis and Paraphimosis: Phimosis is the inability to retract the foreskin completely, while paraphimosis is when the retracted foreskin cannot be returned to its original position. Circumcision eliminates these potential complications.
7. Cultural or Religious Significance: For some families, circumcision holds cultural or religious importance and is a way to uphold traditions.
8. Potential Aesthetic Preference: Some parents may have a personal preference for the appearance of a circumcised penis.
9. Reduced Risk of Some Childhood Infections: Circumcision might be associated with a slightly lower risk of certain childhood infections, such as balanitis xerotica obliterans (BXO).
10. Potential Benefit for Partner’s Health: Some studies suggest a possible reduced risk of cervical cancer in female partners of circumcised men, although the evidence is not conclusive.

10 Risks of circumcision

Here are 10 potential risks associated with circumcision to consider when making a decision:

1. Pain: Circumcision is a surgical procedure, and like any surgery, it can cause pain to the infant. Pain management techniques are used to minimize discomfort, but some level of pain is inevitable.
2. Bleeding: Bleeding is a potential complication during or after the circumcision procedure. While usually minor and easily controlled, it’s still a risk to be aware of.
3. Infection: As with any surgical procedure, there’s a small risk of infection at the circumcision site. Proper hygiene and following post-operative care instructions can help minimize this risk.
4. Accidental Injury: There’s a very small risk of accidental injury to the penis during the circumcision, such as harming the glans or urethra.
5. Meatal Stenosis: This is a narrowing of the opening at the tip of the penis, which can make urination difficult. It’s a rare complication, but it might require additional surgery to correct.
6. Loss of Tissue: Circumcision removes healthy tissue, the foreskin, which some argue has potential benefits like increased sensitivity and lubrication.
7. Psychological Impact: The long-term psychological effects of circumcision on the child are not fully understood and remain a topic of debate.
8. Ethical Considerations: Circumcision is performed on a newborn who cannot consent to the procedure. This raises ethical concerns for some people who believe it’s a violation of bodily autonomy.
9. Cultural and Religious Coercion: In some cultures or religions, pressure to circumcise a child might be strong, potentially leading families to feel pressured into the decision.
10. Limited Long-Term Benefits: While some potential benefits exist, many, like reduced UTI risk in infancy, are temporary or have a very low overall impact on health.
    You can also check the article related to the babies health care Sanfilippo Syndrome
    

    How to recover after Circumcision?

Here’s a guide on how to recover after circumcision, focusing on caring for your newborn or infant:

Immediately After Surgery:

• Pain Management: The doctor will likely administer pain medication before or after the procedure. You can also use swaddling or a pacifier to comfort your baby.

At Home Care:

• Diaper Changes: Change diapers frequently to prevent irritation from urine or stool. Look for diapers with a notch cut out for the penis to avoid sticking.
• Cleaning: Gently clean the circumcision site with warm water at each diaper change. Avoid using soap or harsh cleansers. Pat the area dry with a soft, gauze pad.
• Petroleum Jelly: Apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly to the circumcision site to prevent sticking and promote healing.
• Bathing: Sponge baths are recommended for the first few days to avoid submerging the penis in water. You can resume regular baths once the doctor approves.
• Bleeding: Slight bleeding is normal for the first 1-2 days. If bleeding is excessive, consult your doctor.
• Discomfort: Your baby might experience some discomfort or fussiness. Offer comfort and pain relief medication as prescribed by the doctor.

Signs of Infection:

• Be aware of signs that might indicate infection, such as:
  • Increased redness or swelling around the circumcision site
  • Pus draining from the wound
  • Fever
• If you notice any of these signs, contact your pediatrician immediately.

Healing Timeline:

• The circumcision site typically heals within 7-10 days. The tip of the penis may appear red or bruised for a few weeks, which is normal.

What to Avoid:

• Avoid forceful retraction of the foreskin, which can cause irritation or tearing.
• Don’t apply anything other than petroleum jelly to the circumcision site without consulting your doctor.
• Tight clothing or diapers can irritate the area, so opt for loose-fitting garments.

Doctor Follow-Up:

• Schedule a follow-up appointment with your pediatrician within a week of the circumcision procedure to monitor healing and address any concerns.

Additional Tips:

• Keep a log of diaper changes, noting any bleeding or unusual discharge.
• If your baby seems excessively fussy or inconsolable, consult your doctor.
• Circumcision generally doesn’t interfere with breastfeeding or bottle-feeding.

Remember:

• Every baby heals at their own pace.
• By following these guidelines and your pediatrician’s specific instructions, you can help ensure a smooth recovery for your child after circumcision.
  

Is circumcision painful?

Yes, circumcision is a surgical procedure and does cause pain to the infant. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:

During the Procedure:

• Anesthetics are used to minimize pain during the circumcision. These can be local anesthetics that numb the area or regional anesthetics like a dorsal penile block.
• Despite anesthesia, some level of discomfort is inevitable for the infant.

After the Procedure:

• Pain after circumcision is a common occurrence.
• Pain management techniques are crucial for promoting healing and comfort. These might include:
  • Pain medication prescribed by the doctor
  • Swaddling to provide comfort and security
  • Offering a pacifier for sucking

Individual Sensitivity:

• It’s important to remember that infants have varying pain sensitivities. Some may experience more discomfort than others.

Open Communication with Doctor:

• Discuss pain management options with your pediatrician before the circumcision.
• They can advise on the most appropriate approach for your child and answer any questions you might have.

Focus on Recovery:

• By following post-operative care instructions and providing pain relief measures, you can help your baby heal comfortably after circumcision.

How long does it take circumcision to heal?

The healing process for circumcision typically takes around 7 to 10 days. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:

Initial Healing:

• In the first few days after circumcision, the tip of the penis may appear red, swollen, and bruised. This is a normal part of the healing process.
• Slight bleeding is also common for the first 1-2 days.

Gradual Improvement:

• Over the next 7-10 days, the redness, swelling, and bruising should gradually improve.
• The foreskin may appear dry and yellow, which is a normal part of scab formation.

Complete Healing:

• By the end of the 7-10 day timeframe, the circumcision site should be fully healed.
• The yellow scabbing should disappear, and the tip of the penis should return to its normal color.

Individual Variations:

• It’s important to remember that healing can vary slightly from child to child. Some babies might heal a little faster or slower than this general timeframe.

Signs of Delayed Healing:

• If you notice any signs of delayed healing or potential infection, such as:
  • Increased redness or swelling after the initial few days
  • Pus draining from the wound
  • Fever
• Consult your pediatrician immediately.

Doctor Follow-Up:

• A follow-up appointment with your pediatrician is usually scheduled within a week of the circumcision to monitor healing and address any concerns.

Remember:

• By following your pediatrician’s post-operative care instructions and keeping an eye on the healing process, you can help ensure a smooth recovery for your child after circumcision.

Is adult circumcision safe?

Adult circumcision is generally considered a safe procedure, but like any surgery, it does carry some risks. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:

Safety Considerations:

• Adult circumcision is a more complex procedure compared to circumcision performed on newborns.
• However, when performed by a qualified healthcare professional, it’s a safe and effective procedure for most healthy adults.

Benefits vs. Risks:

• It’s important to weigh the potential benefits of adult circumcision against the risks involved before making a decision.

Benefits:

• May reduce the risk of certain sexually transmitted infections (STIs) like HIV, although safe sex practices are still essential.
• May help prevent some urinary tract infections (UTIs).
• May decrease the risk of balanitis (inflammation of the glans penis).
• Might be performed for religious or cultural reasons.

Risks:

• Bleeding: Some bleeding is possible during or after the procedure.
• Infection: As with any surgery, there’s a small risk of infection at the circumcision site.
• Pain: Adult circumcision is typically performed with local anesthesia, but some discomfort is still expected.
• Meatal stenosis: This is a narrowing of the opening at the tip of the penis, which can make urination difficult. It’s a rare complication, but it might require additional surgery to correct.
• Loss of foreskin: Circumcision removes healthy tissue, and some argue the foreskin has potential benefits like increased sensitivity.
• Psychological impact: The long-term psychological effects of adult circumcision are not fully understood.

Recovery:

• Recovery from adult circumcision typically takes 1-2 weeks.
• You can expect some pain, swelling, and bruising around the penis during this time.

Who Shouldn’t Get Adult Circumcision:

• Adult circumcision might not be recommended for certain individuals with pre-existing medical conditions or those who have difficulty healing from wounds.

Consulting a Doctor:

• If you’re considering adult circumcision, discuss it thoroughly with your doctor. They can assess your individual health situation, explain the risks and benefits in detail, and answer any questions you might have.

Remember:

• The decision of adult circumcision is a personal one. By understanding the potential benefits and risks, and consulting with your doctor, you can make an informed choice about what’s right for you.

What age is OK for circumcision?

Circumcision can be performed at various ages, but the two most common times are:

• Newborn: This is the most common time for circumcision, typically within the first few days or weeks of life. Here are some reasons why parents choose this time:
  • Less Pain: Babies are less sensitive to pain than older children or adults.
  • Faster Healing: Newborns heal quickly, making the recovery process easier.
  • Reduced Risk of Complications: Studies suggest a potential decrease in some complications like UTIs in infancy when circumcision is performed shortly after birth.
• Adulthood: Some men choose to have circumcision later in life for various reasons, including:
  • Medical Reasons: Reduced risk of certain STIs or UTIs, or treatment for conditions like balanitis (inflammation of the glans penis).
  • Religious or Cultural Reasons: Following religious or cultural traditions.
  • Personal Preference: Some men might prefer the appearance of a circumcised penis.

Important Considerations:

• There is no single “best” age for circumcision. The decision is personal and depends on various factors, including cultural or religious beliefs, potential medical benefits and risks, and individual preferences.

Role of Pediatrician:

• Discussing circumcision with your pediatrician is crucial. They can provide information about the procedure, explain the potential benefits and risks at different ages, and help you make an informed decision for your child’s well-being.

Ethical Considerations:

• Circumcision performed on a newborn raises ethical concerns for some people as the infant cannot consent to the procedure. This is a critical factor to consider when making a decision.

Alternatives to Circumcision:

• Maintaining good hygiene of the penis is essential for all males, regardless of circumcision status.
• This can help prevent potential complications like infections.

Remember:

• There’s no right or wrong answer when it comes to circumcision age. Weigh the pros and cons, considering your values and your child’s health, and discuss it with your doctor to make the best choice for your situation.

Why do Muslims get circumcised?

Muslims get circumcised for a combination of religious and cultural reasons. Here’s a breakdown of the main factors:

• Following the Prophet Muhammad’s Tradition (Sunnah): Many Muslims believe circumcision is a practice followed by Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and is therefore considered part of the Sunnah, his teachings and traditions. Some narrations within Islamic texts suggest he was circumcised himself.
• Following the Example of Abraham (AS): Muslims revere Prophet Abraham (AS) as a patriarch and a key figure in their faith. According to Islamic tradition, God commanded Abraham to circumcise himself and his descendants as a sign of their covenant with God.
• Cleanliness (Fitrah): Circumcision is seen by some Muslims as promoting physical cleanliness, a concept emphasized in Islam for prayer and overall well-being.
• Cultural Significance: Circumcision has become a deeply ingrained cultural practice in many Muslim-majority regions. It can be a social custom or a rite of passage for boys, marking their transition towards adulthood.

Important to Note:

• Circumcision is not mandatory in Islam. It’s considered highly recommended (Sunnah) but not compulsory.
• The emphasis in Islam lies more on following the teachings of the Quran and Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) regarding good character and righteous living.
• The decision of whether or not to circumcise a child is ultimately left to the parents.

Similarities with Judaism:

• Circumcision is also practiced in Judaism as a religious covenant with God established with Abraham (considered a prophet in both faiths).

Some Facts and Figures about Circumcision

Some Authentic Sources to get information about Circumcision

• American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP): https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/130/3/585/30235/Circumcision-Policy-Statement
• World Health Organization (WHO): https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/43749/9789241596169_eng.pdf
• Urological Association of America: https://www.urologyhealth.org/educational-resources/circumcision-what-parents-should-know

Briefing

Circumcision is a complex issue with a long history, sparking debates about medicine, culture, and ethics. While there are potential medical benefits and drawbacks to consider, the decision ultimately rests on personal values, cultural or religious beliefs, and what’s deemed best for a child’s well-being. Open communication with a pediatrician is crucial to navigate the various factors and make an informed choice about this impactful practice.

Related Articles 

Circumcision Cuts

What is V-Cut Circumcision?